@Thorvald
El Thorvaldo Moderator

Party Tree
Party Tree by @Thorvald (El Thorvaldo)

Hobbiton movie set, Waikato, New Zealand. Why does the tree look different between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings? The canonical answer is in the original books, after Saruman's defeat at Isengard he takes over the Shire and the tree is cut down; Sam later restores it with a mallorn seed from Galadriel. The practical answer is much of the original landscape used for the set was marsh, and after draining it this face of the tree withered.

Original photo taken May 2014. Submitted to DeviantArt September 2015.


Comments & Critiques (2)

Preferred comment/critique type for this content: Any Kind

Posted: Wednesday, 05 July, 2023 @ 06:09 AM

It fascinates me that New Zealand happened to have everything the trilogy needed.

Posted: Thursday, 06 July, 2023 @ 10:09 PM

@chaseawaythedark: I put it down to the subtropical biome: it's familiar enough to European flora to be recognizable, but different enough to give it that fantasy-exotic feel. I don't know if it was intentionally scouted or Jackson playing to the home country, but needless to say NuZee has become practically synonymous with the Middle-earth aesthetic.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in and have an Active account to leave a comment.
Please, login or sign up for an account.

What kind of comments is Thorvald seeking for this piece?

  • Any Kind - Self-explanatory.
  • Casual Comments - Comments of a more social nature.
  • Light Critique - Comments containing constructive suggestions about this work.
  • Heavy Critique - A serious analysis of this work, with emphasis on identifying potential problem areas, good use of technique and skill, and suggestions for potentially improving the work.
Please keep in mind, critiques may highlight both positive and negative aspects of this work, but the main goal is to constructively help the artist to improve in their skills and execution. Be kind, considerate, and polite.